Philosophical issues : 反《老子》：域中僅二大半

Discussion -> Philosophical issues -> 反《老子》：域中僅二大半

This thread relates to:

Dao De Jing #25

2009-09-18 04:39:32反《老子》：域中僅二大半
Posted by: chunzai (chunzai)	第二十五章域中有四大，而人居其一焉。人法地，地法天，天法道，道法自然。　　　　春齋：其中人是宇宙蛀蟲，不大；道且大且小，只能算半大，所以域中充其量中有二大半春齋
Posted by: chunzai (chunzai)

2010-02-02 13:01:13反《老子》：域中僅二大半
Posted by: leo_fan	无人何以论天、地与道？故人亦大。道之大为大，道之小何尝不是大？
Posted by: leo_fan

2010-10-27 13:42:59反《老子》：域中僅二大半
Posted by: chehwei (chehwei)	此篇应为后人的一个总结性论述，概念上有些易混淆的地方。第1类实体：「三大」：天、地、人；第2类实体：「一大」：自然合为「四大」。两类实体间无形但却充盈的是道吧。（有如宇宙间两颗星体之间真空（真空中其实也有存在））
Posted by: chehwei (chehwei)

2010-11-09 14:49:26反《老子》：域中僅二大半
Posted by: tim_davidson (Tim Davidson)	你好第四十二：道生一，一生二，二生三，三生萬物。莊子: 一與言為二，二與一為三。自此以往，巧曆不能得，而況其凡乎！ I think there is a tendency here to view the world both in terms of opposing dichotomies, such as 小 and 大, and in terms of the old trinity relationship of earth below, human matters in the middle, and heaven above. These are combined in the 易經. The point here is that the creative power of the 道 is both fundamental too and goes beyond this worldview?

2010-11-09 14:49:26反《老子》：域中僅二大半

Posted by: tim_davidson (Tim Davidson)

你好

第四十二：道生一，一生二，二生三，三生萬物。

莊子: 一與言為二，二與一為三。自此以往，巧曆不能得，而況其凡乎！

I think there is a tendency here to view the world both in terms of opposing dichotomies, such as 小 and 大, and in terms of the old trinity relationship of earth below, human matters in the middle, and heaven above. These are combined in the 易經.

The point here is that the creative power of the 道 is both fundamental too and goes beyond this worldview?

2010-12-14 12:51:38反《老子》：域中僅二大半
Posted by: sinolover	依照地下出土简帛，此句「人」当改为「王」，则主旨应该是说王者居国中，而显大。是老子的权谋说辞。
Posted by: sinolover

2011-03-08 20:26:52反《老子》：域中僅二大半
Posted by: 004321 (静笃)	人可逆其道也可顺其道，故为大。人逆道天地亦可毁，怎能不为大！
Posted by: 004321 (静笃)

2013-11-29 19:33:46反《老子》：域中僅二大半

Posted by: volution (fqgd)

Quote: chehwei @ 2010-10-27 13:42:59
此篇应为后人的一个总结性论述，概念上有些易混淆的地方。第1类实体：「三大」：天、地、人；第2类实体：「一大」：自然合为「四大」。两类实体间无形但却充盈的是道吧。（有如宇宙间两颗星体之间真空（真空中其实也有存在））

不应如此解释，域中有四大：人，地，天，道；而自然不在域中。

to 春齋:人也许是地球驻虫，但说是宇宙驻虫就太高看人类在宇宙中的地位了。道且大且小，而无处不在，故成其大。

2014-01-25 23:32:29反《老子》：域中僅二大半
Posted by: sunyang (sunyang)	何為大？大者，人之所不能及也。故人在大之外，無大無不大。天地萬物，精妙無窮，道法自然，玄奧精晦，凡四大矣。
Posted by: sunyang (sunyang)

To participate in the discussion, please log in to your CTP account using the form below. If you don't yet have an account, click here to set one up.

Enjoy this site? Please help.

Site design and content copyright 2006-2024. When quoting or citing information from this site, please link to the corresponding page or to https://ctext.org. Please note that the use of automatic download software on this site is strictly prohibited, and that users of such software are automatically banned without warning to save bandwidth. 沪ICP备09015720号-3

Comments? Suggestions? Please raise them here.