|
Chinese Text Project Wiki |
Simplified Chinese version |
Search details: |
---|
Scope: 四库全书总目提要 |
Condition : References “古易考原” |
Total 3 |
---|
1 | 明梅鷟撰。鷟有《古易考原》,已著录。是编辨正《古文尚书》。其谓二十五篇为皇甫谧所作,盖据孔颖达疏引《晋书皇甫谧传》,称谧姑子外弟梁柳得《古文尚书》,故作《帝王世纪》,往往载孔《传》五十八篇之书云云。然其文未明,未可据为谧作之证。至谓孔安国《序》并增多之二十五篇悉杂取传记中语以成文,则指摘皆有依据。又如谓瀍水出谷城县,《两汉志》并同,晋始省谷城入河南,而孔《传》乃云出河南北山。积石山在西南羌中,汉昭帝始元六年始置金城郡,而孔《传》乃云积石山在金城西南。孔安国卒于汉武时,载在《史记》,则犹在司马迁以前,安得知此地名乎?其为依托,尤佐证显然。陈第作《尚书疏衍》,乃以譸张为幻诋之,过矣。《明史艺文志》不著录。朱彝尊《经义考》作一卷。 |
1 | 明梅鷟撰。鷟有《古易考原》已著录。鷟因宋吴棫、朱子及元吴澄之说作《尚书考异》及此书。《考异》引据颇精核,此则徒以空言诋斥,无所依据。如谓孔壁之十六篇出于孔安国所为,实以臆断之,别无确证。又谓东晋之二十五篇出于皇甫谧所为,则但据孔颖达引《晋书谧传》「从其姑子外弟梁柳得古文」一语,其说亦在影响之间。且辞气叫嚣,动辄丑詈,亦非著书之体。故录其《考异》,而是书仅存目焉。 |
Enjoy this site? Please help. | Site design and content copyright 2006-2024. When quoting or citing information from this site, please link to the corresponding page or to https://ctext.org/ens. Please note that the use of automatic download software on this site is strictly prohibited, and that users of such software are automatically banned without warning to save bandwidth. 沪ICP备09015720号-3 | Comments? Suggestions? Please raise them here. |